This is a problem that has been going on since the beginning of modern commerce. Actually I’m sure it’s been going on since ancient times during the good old barter system. Here’s the problem; obviously consumers want as many leads as possible, period. The common misconception is that the more leads you have, inevitably the more business you will make (given you’re product is actually marketable). While logically this makes sense it is far from the truth.
This is where quality plays a key role in lead generation. Sure, a company like Home Depot can go out and buy a million leads but what are they getting out of that? Low quality leads means it will be harder for them to sell their product, disinterested contacts and bogus information. So yes the amount of leads was massive, but how many actual sales were converted? Hardly any, meaning ROI is way down. Now make quality of leads a factor in the situation and you can see that quantity really means nothing. That same company can use less money to purchase one thousand good, high quality leads and turn more of them into real sales because they are dealing with consumers who are actively interested in their product or services.
You can think of this as almost an equation.
Q = Quality (as a percentage)
A = Amount
S= Sales
A x Q = S ex. 1) 100,000 x 0.001 = 100 ex.2) 1000 x 0.99 = 999
If you’re quality percentage is extremely low (0.1% or .001) you’re not going to net very many sales, but if your quality is quite high (99% or .99) your sales will skyrocket.
Now the question is how do you determine if a lead is high quality or not? It all depends on how the lead was attained. Was a consumer forced to give their information in order to obtain something else (i.e. co-registration) or maybe some sort of gimmick was involved in order to create a lead which really isn’t there (e-mail blasts). Quality leads are obtained by gathering information from consumers who are actively looking for your services or products. When a potential customer is looking for you, you know they are definitely interested in what you have to offer. This is why search engine marketing and optimization are key to generating successful, quality leads.
Sure a massive amount of low quality leads will sell, but for how long? Once a client realizes that their ROI is horrible you can be sure they are going to look elsewhere for their leads. A successful lead generation business will invest heavily in search marketing to obtain high quality leads which keep clients happy.